When Theodora met Connor—wealthy, charming, and a member of the powerful Daltons—she fell in love instantly. Six months later, he’s brought her to Idlewood, his family’s isolated winter retreat. |
All relationships are rife with the potential for secrets big or small, and family relationships are no different. Whether it’s a secret kept within a family or from each other, inevitably someone’s left out of the equation. Secrets in families can take on an elevated level of tension and betrayal. Someone you live among, sleep beside, or see every day is somehow hiding a life-changing tidbit of information. They have a second life or committed some terrible action, or they built a life on a lie.
In families, it’s not always the big secrets that can spread chaos through its members. Even the smallest thing can set off a chain reaction of drama. The warning signs, the close calls, the hiding in plain sight: it all makes for a great story.
This is especially true when it comes to mysteries and thrillers. A disappearance or strange encounter that seems entirely unrelated to a character can be the inciting incident that brings a long-hidden truth into the light. An investigation can uncover more than what anyone bargained for. A character can turn out to need to turn to their own family history to solve the case.
If mysteries about family secrets sound up your alley, check out these eight excellent options!
Everything I Never Told You by Celeste NgLydia Lee is 16 and the middle child of her family, feeling pressure from her parents to succeed both educationally and socially. Then, one morning, she’s found dead. As the family spirals in the aftermath of her mysterious death, cracks in the family’s foundation appear. With storylines alternating between the Lee’s past in the 1950s and the present in the 1970s, family secrets play a key role in what happened to Lydia and why. |
The Family Upstairs by Lisa JewellWhen Libby was a baby, she was adopted. Now, she’s turning 25 and a letter arrives with the names of her birth parents inside along with a revelation that she inherited a mansion. But the mansion turns out to be in rough shape and, with it, comes a history with its own fill of secrets Libby wasn’t expecting to find. |
The Leftover Woman by Jean KwokFleeing an abusive husband in China, Jasmine Yang winds up in New York with no money and nowhere to turn. But, she has a goal: to find the daughter that was taken from her. Her journey intersects with Rebecca, a wealthy woman with a professor husband and an adopted daughter navigating a workplace scandal. How will their paths intersect? Pick this up to find out! |
Not a Happy Family by Shari LapenaIt’s Easter and the Merton family begrudgingly gets together to enjoy a meal together in their upstate New York home. But that night, Fred Merton and his wife Shelia are murdered. With a large inheritance on the line and family secrets lurking, the culprit could be anyone, including their own children. |
The Family Plot by Megan CollinsDeath doesn’t make Dahlia Lighthouse blink twice. She was raised in a true-crime-obsessed family, after all, and her childhood was full of murder documentaries and reenactments as part of her homeschool curriculum. At 16, her twin brother left their home with only a note in his place. Now, 10 years after leaving her morbid home, Dahlia must return for the burial of her father. But inside her father’s assigned grave is the body of her twin brother. What happened a decade ago and who put him there? Dahlia’s unique education might be exactly what she needed to find out. |
Sharp Objects by Gillian FlynnJournalist Camille Preaker did everything she could to leave her hometown and her mother behind. But when two teenage girls are found dead with their teeth removed, she’s compelled to investigate. Now, she must face her cold mother and her 13-year-old half-sister while getting to the bottom of what was happening to young girls in the town she so desperately wanted to leave behind. |
Little Secrets by Jennifer HillierMarin Machado is living her dreams. She’s married to entrepreneur Derek, running her own hair salons, and raising their little boy, Sebastian. But when Sebastian is kidnapped from a shopping center, the close eyes of the police and a private investigator threaten to shatter Marin’s perfect life. |
The God of the Woods by Liz MooreIn the summer of 1975, Barbara Van Laar, daughter of the Van Laar family, goes missing from her family-owned summer camp. She’s not the first of the Van Laar family to disappear from that very land. Fourteen years ago, her brother, Bear, disappeared. As history repeats itself, the Van Laar family and those employed by them are thrust back into the spotlight, revealing social dynamics and family secrets alike. |
I hope you found one of these mysteries about family secrets intriguing enough to pick up! If you’re looking for more mysteries, check out these new January releases or these family thrillers!